JCY: Well Jason, first off I’d like to thank you for taking the time out of your day to do this interview.
JB: No problem, man. I was happy to do it.
JCY: I gotta say I’ve been hoping for the opportunity to interview you for some time, so I’m glad we could make this work.
JB: I don’t do many interviews anyway nowadays. Hopefully I’m not too rusty.
JCY: So, how are things? It seems like you’ve been on a kind of acting hiatus lately and focused way more time on family.
JB: Yeah, well my wife and I just had our second kid, so I’ve been needed a lot more around the house lately. It’s been great though, giving her a break and doing some hardcore daddy time, while she rests.
JCY: I think it’s great that you do that. Do you ever find it difficult to do something like that and try and jump back in to the industry or is it pretty easy for you to get jobs when you’re available.
JB: It’s a little bit of both, actually. Nowadays, I’m not really getting the lead roles like I used to, but I’m always happy to do a supporting role here or there. Gives me more time at home.
JCY: Now, most people from my generation would know you from the American Pie series. Has that been a hard role for you to escape?
JB: You know, I’m really proud of the work that I did with those guys and that cast. I don’t think any one of us thought it was going to make it to four movies when we were shooting the first one, so in a way I’m actually really grateful for everything. Has that character ever prevented me from seeing other roles? Sure. Maybe. I’m in a good place though. I’m happy. And I’m confident that I have a lot of good acting years still ahead of me.
JCY: I don’t think people realize how great of a comedy American Pie was and still is to this day. Even though I was in elementary school, that movie seemed to capture a certain essence that other comedies struggled to show. The relationships just seemed super real.
JB: Yeah, man. I think we had a really great team working on it too, so that definitely helped. All the actors and crew were so tuned in during filming. We all knew how funny it was going to be.
JCY: Do you still keep in touch with those guys? Chris? Seann? Alyson and Shannon?
JB: I do. Not as often as I would like, probably, but we’re all just so busy. It was nice to have those sequels because it kind of brought us all back together, but like I said, not as much as we would hope. We all follow what we’re doing, though. We’re a family.
JCY: To be honest, it seems like a lot of you guys experienced your cinematic peak in those movies. Why do you think it’s been so hard for all of you to reestablish yourselves in the industry and in different roles?
JB: Like you said earlier, I think American Pie was a really successful niche comedy. A lot of high school comedies were and now that I think about it, there haven’t been a lot of examples of people really stepping outside that arena after they got that initial success. Maybe there have been, but I think because our movie was so successful and beloved by those young people—such great characters all around—it was hard for us to find ourselves.
JCY: I didn’t realize this, but 1999 and 2000 were crazy years for teen movies! I mean there was “She’s All That”, “Cruel Intentions”, “10 Things I Hate About You”, “Never Been Kissed”, “Varsity Blues”, “Bring It On”, “Teaching Miss Tingle”, “The Faculty”, “Idle Hands”, “The Skulls”…the list goes on. For people born in the late 80’s and early 90’s those were classics!
JB: That is pretty nuts. A lot of talented actors, too.
JCY: A lot of people don’t know you started on stage. You were 12 years old when you made your Broadway debut.
JB: Yup. “Conversations With My Father.”
JCY: What was that like? Did it help you?
JB: I don’t think stage acting can do anything but help you. That was an amazing cast. Judd Hirsch, of course, but also Tony Shaloub, David Marguiles, and my good buddy David Krumholtz. I remember learning so much from those amazing actors and being inspired by them.
JCY: You also were in “The Graduate” and “Heidi Chronicles.”
JB: I was. Great experiences as well with wonderful actors.
JCY: “The Graduate” was such an iconic movie and Benjamin Braddock was such an iconic character. Did you have trouble making it your own?
JB: I didn’t have trouble making it my own. I knew that I wanted to handle it with care and respect because of how iconic it was. It would have been wrong of me to treat it any other way.
JCY: Did it disappoint you that it wasn’t very well received during its run?
JB: Things happen. I think we all did great work. That’s the nature of the business, though. If you don’t make a certain amount of money—it was too bad.
JCY: Do you hope to make a return to the stage in the future?
JB: Of course! The stage is a great place to retrain and recalibrate. I think I’ve always felt more comfortable on screen over the years. It’s a welcomed challenge when I do stage work. You can’t cheat.
JCY: Jason, when you’re kids come of age, will you show them American Pie and tell them that that was your best work?
JB: Best work? Come on… I take it you haven’t seen “Anything Else”?
JCY: Nope. I missed that one.
JB: I’ll be sure to tell them that people their age loved this when it came out and that those same people, like you, still love it to this day. Hopefully they understand that.
JCY: I’m sure they will. Just curious, are you gonna show them that whole Nadia scene? I remember when I first saw it at home my mom told me to leave the room.
JB: That’s a great question. I guess I’ll have to leave that up to their mother.